A Compass for Useful Data: Online Data Selection via Alignment-Gated Fisher Geometry

Online data selection is typically driven by per-sample scores such as loss, uncertainty, or gradient norm, which measure how strongly the model reacts to a candidate but not what parameter update the candidate would induce. What an online learner should select is therefore not the most striking example, but the one whose update is most worth taking. To make this concrete, we score a candidate by the movement induced by its update, using a Fisher-whitened information gain that evaluates the update in the loss geometry rather than by raw gradient size. Movement, however, is not yet progress, so we pass this score through a \emph{Descent Alignment Gate}, a soft factor that retains it only when the induced update agrees with the descent direction. This yields a sample-level score favoring updates that are both informative and descent-aligned. To make the criterion compatible with training, we extend it from samples to batches, where selected updates should not only score well individually but also complement one another. We capture this with the \emph{Gated Fisher Volume}, a log-determinant batch objective that reduces to the per-sample score on a singleton, grows with the volume spanned by the chosen updates in the Fisher geometry, and admits a greedy algorithm with a constant-factor approximation guarantee. Across supervised fine-tuning benchmarks, our selector consistently outperforms online selection baselines under matched training budgets. More broadly, the framework reframes data selection itself: rather than a spotlight on conspicuous examples, it acts as a compass toward updates worth taking.