Timezone: »
Face recognition systems are used widely but are known to exhibit bias across a range of sociodemographic dimensions, such as gender and race. An array of works proposing pre-processing, training, and post-processing methods have failed to close these gaps. Here, we take a very different approach to this problem, identifying that both architectures and hyperparameters of neural networks are instrumental in reducing bias. We first run a large-scale analysis of the impact of architectures and training hyperparameters on several common fairness metrics and show that the implicit convention of choosing high-accuracy architectures may be suboptimal for fairness. Motivated by our findings, we run the first neural architecture search for fairness, jointly with a search for hyperparameters. We output a suite of models which Pareto-dominate all other competitive architectures in terms of accuracy and fairness. Furthermore, we show that these models transfer well to other face recognition datasets with similar and distinct protected attributes. We release our code and raw result files so that researchers and practitioners can replace our fairness metrics with a bias measure of their choice.
Author Information
Samuel Dooley (Department of Computer Science, University of Maryland, College Park)
Rhea Sukthanker (University of Freiburg, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg)
John Dickerson (Arthur AI & University of Maryland)
Colin White (Abacus.AI)
Frank Hutter (University of Freiburg & Bosch)
Frank Hutter is a Full Professor for Machine Learning at the Computer Science Department of the University of Freiburg (Germany), where he previously was an assistant professor 2013-2017. Before that, he was at the University of British Columbia (UBC) for eight years, for his PhD and postdoc. Frank's main research interests lie in machine learning, artificial intelligence and automated algorithm design. For his 2009 PhD thesis on algorithm configuration, he received the CAIAC doctoral dissertation award for the best thesis in AI in Canada that year, and with his coauthors, he received several best paper awards and prizes in international competitions on machine learning, SAT solving, and AI planning. Since 2016 he holds an ERC Starting Grant for a project on automating deep learning based on Bayesian optimization, Bayesian neural networks, and deep reinforcement learning.
Micah Goldblum (University of Maryland)
More from the Same Authors
-
2020 : An Open Review of OpenReview: A Critical Analysis of the Machine Learning Conference Review Process »
David Tran · Alex Valtchanov · Keshav R Ganapathy · Raymond Feng · Eric Slud · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein -
2021 : OpenML Benchmarking Suites »
Bernd Bischl · Giuseppe Casalicchio · Matthias Feurer · Pieter Gijsbers · Frank Hutter · Michel Lang · Rafael Gomes Mantovani · Jan van Rijn · Joaquin Vanschoren -
2021 : HPOBench: A Collection of Reproducible Multi-Fidelity Benchmark Problems for HPO »
Katharina Eggensperger · Philipp Müller · Neeratyoy Mallik · Matthias Feurer · Rene Sass · Aaron Klein · Noor Awad · Marius Lindauer · Frank Hutter -
2021 : Synthetic Benchmarks for Scientific Research in Explainable Machine Learning »
Yang Liu · Sujay Khandagale · Colin White · Willie Neiswanger -
2021 : A Closer Look at Distribution Shifts and Out-of-Distribution Generalization on Graphs »
Mucong Ding · Kezhi Kong · Jiuhai Chen · John Kirchenbauer · Micah Goldblum · David P Wipf · Furong Huang · Tom Goldstein -
2021 : Transformers Can Do Bayesian-Inference By Meta-Learning on Prior-Data »
Samuel Müller · Noah Hollmann · Sebastian Pineda Arango · Josif Grabocka · Frank Hutter -
2021 : Learning Revenue-Maximizing Auctions With Differentiable Matching »
Michael Curry · Uro Lyi · Tom Goldstein · John P Dickerson -
2021 : Learning Revenue-Maximizing Auctions With Differentiable Matching »
Michael Curry · Uro Lyi · Tom Goldstein · John P Dickerson -
2021 : An mHealth Intervention for African American and Hispanic Adults: Preliminary Results from a One-Year Field Test »
Christine Herlihy · John Dickerson -
2021 : An mHealth Intervention for African American and Hispanic Adults: Preliminary Results from a One-Year Field Test »
Christine Herlihy · John Dickerson -
2022 : c-TPE: Generalizing Tree-structured Parzen Estimator with Inequality Constraints for Continuous and Categorical Hyperparameter Optimization »
Shuhei Watanabe · Frank Hutter -
2022 : Investigating Reproducibility from the Decision Boundary Perspective. »
Gowthami Somepalli · Arpit Bansal · Liam Fowl · Ping-yeh Chiang · Yehuda Dar · Richard Baraniuk · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein -
2022 : A Deep Dive into Dataset Imbalance and Bias in Face Identification »
Valeriia Cherepanova · Steven Reich · Samuel Dooley · Hossein Souri · John Dickerson · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein -
2022 : SAINT: Improved Neural Networks for Tabular Data via Row Attention and Contrastive Pre-Training »
Gowthami Somepalli · Avi Schwarzschild · Micah Goldblum · C. Bayan Bruss · Tom Goldstein -
2022 : Transfer Learning with Deep Tabular Models »
Roman Levin · Valeriia Cherepanova · Avi Schwarzschild · Arpit Bansal · C. Bayan Bruss · Tom Goldstein · Andrew Wilson · Micah Goldblum -
2022 : TabPFN: A Transformer That Solves Small Tabular Classification Problems in a Second »
Noah Hollmann · Samuel Müller · Katharina Eggensperger · Frank Hutter -
2022 : Tensions Between the Proxies of Human Values in AI »
Daniel Nissani · Teresa Datta · John Dickerson · Max Cembalest · Akash Khanna · Haley Massa -
2022 : AutoML for Climate Change: A Call to Action »
Renbo Tu · Nicholas Roberts · Vishak Prasad C · Sibasis Nayak · Paarth Jain · Frederic Sala · Ganesh Ramakrishnan · Ameet Talwalkar · Willie Neiswanger · Colin White -
2022 : Characterizing Anomalies with Explainable Classifiers »
Naveen Durvasula · Valentine d Hauteville · Keegan Hines · John Dickerson -
2022 : A Deep Dive into Dataset Imbalance and Bias in Face Identification »
Valeriia Cherepanova · Steven Reich · Samuel Dooley · Hossein Souri · John Dickerson · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein -
2022 : On the Importance of Architectures and Hyperparameters for Fairness in Face Recognition »
Samuel Dooley · Rhea Sukthanker · John Dickerson · Colin White · Frank Hutter · Micah Goldblum -
2022 : Efficient Bayesian Learning Curve Extrapolation using Prior-Data Fitted Networks »
Steven Adriaensen · Herilalaina Rakotoarison · Samuel Müller · Frank Hutter -
2022 : Transfer NAS with Meta-learned Bayesian Surrogates »
Gresa Shala · Thomas Elsken · Frank Hutter · Josif Grabocka -
2022 : Gray-Box Gaussian Processes for Automated Reinforcement Learning »
Gresa Shala · André Biedenkapp · Frank Hutter · Josif Grabocka -
2022 : AutoRL-Bench 1.0 »
Gresa Shala · Sebastian Pineda Arango · André Biedenkapp · Frank Hutter · Josif Grabocka -
2022 : Bayesian Optimization with a Neural Network Meta-learned on Synthetic Data Only »
Samuel Müller · Sebastian Pineda Arango · Matthias Feurer · Josif Grabocka · Frank Hutter -
2022 : GraViT-E: Gradient-based Vision Transformer Search with Entangled Weights »
Rhea Sukthanker · Arjun Krishnakumar · sharat patil · Frank Hutter -
2022 : PriorBand: HyperBand + Human Expert Knowledge »
Neeratyoy Mallik · Carl Hvarfner · Danny Stoll · Maciej Janowski · Edward Bergman · Marius Lindauer · Luigi Nardi · Frank Hutter -
2022 : Towards Discovering Neural Architectures from Scratch »
Simon Schrodi · Danny Stoll · Robin Ru · Rhea Sukthanker · Thomas Brox · Frank Hutter -
2022 : Multi-objective Tree-structured Parzen Estimator Meets Meta-learning »
Shuhei Watanabe · Noor Awad · Masaki Onishi · Frank Hutter -
2022 : A Deep Dive into Dataset Imbalance and Bias in Face Identification »
Valeriia Cherepanova · Steven Reich · Samuel Dooley · Hossein Souri · John Dickerson · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein -
2022 : Canary in a Coalmine: Better Membership Inference with Ensembled Adversarial Queries »
Yuxin Wen · Arpit Bansal · Hamid Kazemi · Eitan Borgnia · Micah Goldblum · Jonas Geiping · Tom Goldstein -
2022 : On Representation Learning Under Class Imbalance »
Ravid Shwartz-Ziv · Micah Goldblum · Yucen Li · C. Bayan Bruss · Andrew Gordon Wilson -
2022 Workshop: Graph Learning for Industrial Applications: Finance, Crime Detection, Medicine and Social Media »
Manuela Veloso · John Dickerson · Senthil Kumar · Eren K. · Jian Tang · Jie Chen · Peter Henstock · Susan Tibbs · Ani Calinescu · Naftali Cohen · C. Bayan Bruss · Armineh Nourbakhsh -
2022 : TabPFN: A Transformer That Solves Small Tabular Classification Problems in a Second »
Noah Hollmann · Samuel Müller · Katharina Eggensperger · Frank Hutter -
2022 : Transfer Learning with Deep Tabular Models »
Roman Levin · Valeriia Cherepanova · Avi Schwarzschild · Arpit Bansal · C. Bayan Bruss · Tom Goldstein · Andrew Wilson · Micah Goldblum -
2022 Social: Open Mic Night »
John Dickerson -
2022 Poster: Where do Models go Wrong? Parameter-Space Saliency Maps for Explainability »
Roman Levin · Manli Shu · Eitan Borgnia · Furong Huang · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein -
2022 Poster: Robustness Disparities in Face Detection »
Samuel Dooley · George Z Wei · Tom Goldstein · John Dickerson -
2022 Poster: Chroma-VAE: Mitigating Shortcut Learning with Generative Classifiers »
Wanqian Yang · Polina Kirichenko · Micah Goldblum · Andrew Wilson -
2022 Poster: Pre-Train Your Loss: Easy Bayesian Transfer Learning with Informative Priors »
Ravid Shwartz-Ziv · Micah Goldblum · Hossein Souri · Sanyam Kapoor · Chen Zhu · Yann LeCun · Andrew Wilson -
2022 Poster: Joint Entropy Search For Maximally-Informed Bayesian Optimization »
Carl Hvarfner · Frank Hutter · Luigi Nardi -
2022 Poster: Autoregressive Perturbations for Data Poisoning »
Pedro Sandoval-Segura · Vasu Singla · Jonas Geiping · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein · David Jacobs -
2022 Poster: Probabilistic Transformer: Modelling Ambiguities and Distributions for RNA Folding and Molecule Design »
Jörg Franke · Frederic Runge · Frank Hutter -
2022 Poster: On the Generalizability and Predictability of Recommender Systems »
Duncan McElfresh · Sujay Khandagale · Jonathan Valverde · John Dickerson · Colin White -
2022 Poster: NAS-Bench-Suite-Zero: Accelerating Research on Zero Cost Proxies »
Arjun Krishnakumar · Colin White · Arber Zela · Renbo Tu · Mahmoud Safari · Frank Hutter -
2022 Poster: Sleeper Agent: Scalable Hidden Trigger Backdoors for Neural Networks Trained from Scratch »
Hossein Souri · Liam Fowl · Rama Chellappa · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein -
2022 Poster: JAHS-Bench-201: A Foundation For Research On Joint Architecture And Hyperparameter Search »
Archit Bansal · Danny Stoll · Maciej Janowski · Arber Zela · Frank Hutter -
2022 Poster: PAC-Bayes Compression Bounds So Tight That They Can Explain Generalization »
Sanae Lotfi · Marc Finzi · Sanyam Kapoor · Andres Potapczynski · Micah Goldblum · Andrew Wilson -
2022 Poster: End-to-end Algorithm Synthesis with Recurrent Networks: Extrapolation without Overthinking »
Arpit Bansal · Avi Schwarzschild · Eitan Borgnia · Zeyad Emam · Furong Huang · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein -
2021 : CARL: A Benchmark for Contextual and Adaptive Reinforcement Learning »
Carolin Benjamins · Theresa Eimer · Frederik Schubert · André Biedenkapp · Bodo Rosenhahn · Frank Hutter · Marius Lindauer -
2021 : A Closer Look at Distribution Shifts and Out-of-Distribution Generalization on Graphs »
Mucong Ding · Kezhi Kong · Jiuhai Chen · John Kirchenbauer · Micah Goldblum · David P Wipf · Furong Huang · Tom Goldstein -
2021 Workshop: 5th Workshop on Meta-Learning »
Erin Grant · Fábio Ferreira · Frank Hutter · Jonathan Richard Schwarz · Joaquin Vanschoren · Huaxiu Yao -
2021 Poster: How Powerful are Performance Predictors in Neural Architecture Search? »
Colin White · Arber Zela · Robin Ru · Yang Liu · Frank Hutter -
2021 Poster: Can You Learn an Algorithm? Generalizing from Easy to Hard Problems with Recurrent Networks »
Avi Schwarzschild · Eitan Borgnia · Arjun Gupta · Furong Huang · Uzi Vishkin · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein -
2021 Poster: VQ-GNN: A Universal Framework to Scale up Graph Neural Networks using Vector Quantization »
Mucong Ding · Kezhi Kong · Jingling Li · Chen Zhu · John Dickerson · Furong Huang · Tom Goldstein -
2021 Poster: Fair Clustering Under a Bounded Cost »
Seyed Esmaeili · Brian Brubach · Aravind Srinivasan · John Dickerson -
2021 Poster: PreferenceNet: Encoding Human Preferences in Auction Design with Deep Learning »
Neehar Peri · Michael Curry · Samuel Dooley · John Dickerson -
2021 Poster: Well-tuned Simple Nets Excel on Tabular Datasets »
Arlind Kadra · Marius Lindauer · Frank Hutter · Josif Grabocka -
2021 Poster: NAS-Bench-x11 and the Power of Learning Curves »
Shen Yan · Colin White · Yash Savani · Frank Hutter -
2021 Poster: How does a Neural Network's Architecture Impact its Robustness to Noisy Labels? »
Jingling Li · Mozhi Zhang · Keyulu Xu · John Dickerson · Jimmy Ba -
2021 Poster: Adversarial Examples Make Strong Poisons »
Liam Fowl · Micah Goldblum · Ping-yeh Chiang · Jonas Geiping · Wojciech Czaja · Tom Goldstein -
2021 Poster: Encoding Robustness to Image Style via Adversarial Feature Perturbations »
Manli Shu · Zuxuan Wu · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein -
2021 Poster: Neural Ensemble Search for Uncertainty Estimation and Dataset Shift »
Sheheryar Zaidi · Arber Zela · Thomas Elsken · Chris C Holmes · Frank Hutter · Yee Teh -
2020 Workshop: Workshop on Dataset Curation and Security »
Nathalie Baracaldo · Yonatan Bisk · Avrim Blum · Michael Curry · John Dickerson · Micah Goldblum · Tom Goldstein · Bo Li · Avi Schwarzschild -
2020 : Q/A for invited talk #1 »
Frank Hutter -
2020 : Meta-learning neural architectures, initial weights, hyperparameters, and algorithm components »
Frank Hutter -
2020 Poster: A Study on Encodings for Neural Architecture Search »
Colin White · Willie Neiswanger · Sam Nolen · Yash Savani -
2020 Spotlight: A Study on Encodings for Neural Architecture Search »
Colin White · Willie Neiswanger · Sam Nolen · Yash Savani -
2020 Poster: Detection as Regression: Certified Object Detection with Median Smoothing »
Ping-yeh Chiang · Michael Curry · Ahmed Abdelkader · Aounon Kumar · John Dickerson · Tom Goldstein -
2020 Poster: Adversarially Robust Few-Shot Learning: A Meta-Learning Approach »
Micah Goldblum · Liam Fowl · Tom Goldstein -
2020 Poster: Intra-Processing Methods for Debiasing Neural Networks »
Yash Savani · Colin White · Naveen Sundar Govindarajulu -
2020 Poster: Certifying Strategyproof Auction Networks »
Michael Curry · Ping-yeh Chiang · Tom Goldstein · John Dickerson -
2020 Poster: Improving Policy-Constrained Kidney Exchange via Pre-Screening »
Duncan McElfresh · Michael Curry · Tuomas Sandholm · John Dickerson -
2020 Poster: Probabilistic Fair Clustering »
Seyed Esmaeili · Brian Brubach · Leonidas Tsepenekas · John Dickerson -
2019 : Frank Hutter (University of Freiburg) "A Proposal for a New Competition Design Emphasizing Scientific Insights" »
Frank Hutter -
2019 : Coffee/Poster session 1 »
Shiro Takagi · Khurram Javed · Johanna Sommer · Amr Sharaf · Pierluca D'Oro · Ying Wei · Sivan Doveh · Colin White · Santiago Gonzalez · Cuong Nguyen · Mao Li · Tianhe Yu · Tiago Ramalho · Masahiro Nomura · Ahsan Alvi · Jean-Francois Ton · W. Ronny Huang · Jessica Lee · Sebastian Flennerhag · Michael Zhang · Abram Friesen · Paul Blomstedt · Alina Dubatovka · Sergey Bartunov · Subin Yi · Iaroslav Shcherbatyi · Christian Simon · Zeyuan Shang · David MacLeod · Lu Liu · Liam Fowl · Diego Mesquita · Deirdre Quillen -
2019 Workshop: Meta-Learning »
Roberto Calandra · Ignasi Clavera Gilaberte · Frank Hutter · Joaquin Vanschoren · Jane Wang -
2019 Poster: Making the Cut: A Bandit-based Approach to Tiered Interviewing »
Candice Schumann · Zhi Lang · Jeffrey Foster · John Dickerson -
2019 Poster: Meta-Surrogate Benchmarking for Hyperparameter Optimization »
Aaron Klein · Zhenwen Dai · Frank Hutter · Neil Lawrence · Javier González -
2019 Poster: Adversarial training for free! »
Ali Shafahi · Mahyar Najibi · Mohammad Amin Ghiasi · Zheng Xu · John Dickerson · Christoph Studer · Larry Davis · Gavin Taylor · Tom Goldstein -
2018 Workshop: NIPS 2018 Workshop on Meta-Learning »
Joaquin Vanschoren · Frank Hutter · Sachin Ravi · Jane Wang · Erin Grant -
2018 Poster: Maximizing acquisition functions for Bayesian optimization »
James Wilson · Frank Hutter · Marc Deisenroth -
2018 Poster: Data-Driven Clustering via Parameterized Lloyd's Families »
Maria-Florina Balcan · Travis Dick · Colin White -
2018 Spotlight: Data-Driven Clustering via Parameterized Lloyd's Families »
Maria-Florina Balcan · Travis Dick · Colin White -
2018 Tutorial: Automatic Machine Learning »
Frank Hutter · Joaquin Vanschoren -
2017 Workshop: Workshop on Meta-Learning »
Roberto Calandra · Frank Hutter · Hugo Larochelle · Sergey Levine -
2016 : Invited talk, Frank Hutter »
Frank Hutter -
2016 Workshop: Bayesian Optimization: Black-box Optimization and Beyond »
Roberto Calandra · Bobak Shahriari · Javier Gonzalez · Frank Hutter · Ryan Adams -
2016 : Frank Hutter (University Freiburg) »
Frank Hutter -
2016 Poster: Bayesian Optimization with Robust Bayesian Neural Networks »
Jost Tobias Springenberg · Aaron Klein · Stefan Falkner · Frank Hutter -
2016 Oral: Bayesian Optimization with Robust Bayesian Neural Networks »
Jost Tobias Springenberg · Aaron Klein · Stefan Falkner · Frank Hutter -
2015 : Scalable and Flexible Bayesian Optimization for Algorithm Configuration »
Frank Hutter -
2015 : Uncertainty in Dynamic Matching »
John P Dickerson -
2015 Poster: Efficient and Robust Automated Machine Learning »
Matthias Feurer · Aaron Klein · Katharina Eggensperger · Jost Springenberg · Manuel Blum · Frank Hutter