Timezone: »
Uncertainty estimation (UE) techniques---such as the Gaussian process (GP), Bayesian neural networks (BNN), Monte Carlo dropout (MCDropout)---aim to improve the interpretability of machine learning models by assigning an estimated uncertainty value to each of their prediciton outputs. However, since too high uncertainty estimates can have fatal consequences in practice, this paper analyzes the above techniques.Firstly, we show that GP methods always yield high uncertainty estimates on out of distribution (OOD) data. Secondly, we show on a 2D toy example that both BNNs and MCDropout do not give high uncertainty estimates on OOD samples. Finally, we show empirically that this pitfall of BNNs and MCDropout holds on real world datasets as well. Our insights (i) raise awareness for the more cautious use of currently popular UE methods in Deep Learning, (ii) encourage the development of UE methods that approximate GP-based methods---instead of BNNs and MCDropout, and (iii) our empirical setups can be used for verifying the OOD performances of any other UE method.
Author Information
Yehao Liu (EPFL)
Matteo Pagliardini (Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Lausanne)
Tatjana Chavdarova (UC Berkeley)
Sebastian Stich (CISPA)
Dr. [Sebastian U. Stich](https://sstich.ch/) is a faculty at the CISPA Helmholtz Center for Information Security. Research interests: - *methods for machine learning and statistics*—at the interface of theory and practice - *collaborative learning* (distributed, federated and decentralized methods) - *optimization for machine learning* (adaptive stochastic methods and generalization performance)
More from the Same Authors
-
2021 : Escaping Local Minima With Stochastic Noise »
Harshvardhan Harshvardhan · Sebastian Stich -
2022 : Diversity through Disagreement for Better Transferability »
Matteo Pagliardini · Martin Jaggi · François Fleuret · Sai Praneeth Karimireddy -
2021 : Contributed Talks in Session 1 (Zoom) »
Sebastian Stich · Futong Liu · Abdurakhmon Sadiev · Frederik Benzing · Simon Roburin -
2021 : Opening Remarks to Session 1 »
Sebastian Stich -
2021 Workshop: OPT 2021: Optimization for Machine Learning »
Courtney Paquette · Quanquan Gu · Oliver Hinder · Katya Scheinberg · Sebastian Stich · Martin Takac -
2021 Poster: Breaking the centralized barrier for cross-device federated learning »
Sai Praneeth Karimireddy · Martin Jaggi · Satyen Kale · Mehryar Mohri · Sashank Reddi · Sebastian Stich · Ananda Theertha Suresh -
2021 Poster: RelaySum for Decentralized Deep Learning on Heterogeneous Data »
Thijs Vogels · Lie He · Anastasiia Koloskova · Sai Praneeth Karimireddy · Tao Lin · Sebastian Stich · Martin Jaggi -
2021 Poster: An Improved Analysis of Gradient Tracking for Decentralized Machine Learning »
Anastasiia Koloskova · Tao Lin · Sebastian Stich -
2020 : Closing remarks »
Quanquan Gu · Courtney Paquette · Mark Schmidt · Sebastian Stich · Martin Takac -
2020 : Contributed talks in Session 1 (Zoom) »
Sebastian Stich · Laurent Condat · Zhize Li · Ohad Shamir · Tiffany Vlaar · Mohammadi Zaki -
2020 : Live Q&A with Volkan Cevher (Zoom) »
Sebastian Stich -
2020 : Live Q&A with Tong Zhang (Zoom) »
Sebastian Stich -
2020 : Welcome remarks to Session 1 »
Sebastian Stich -
2020 Workshop: OPT2020: Optimization for Machine Learning »
Courtney Paquette · Mark Schmidt · Sebastian Stich · Quanquan Gu · Martin Takac -
2020 : Welcome event (gather.town) »
Quanquan Gu · Courtney Paquette · Mark Schmidt · Sebastian Stich · Martin Takac -
2020 Poster: Ensemble Distillation for Robust Model Fusion in Federated Learning »
Tao Lin · Lingjing Kong · Sebastian Stich · Martin Jaggi -
2018 Poster: Accelerated Stochastic Matrix Inversion: General Theory and Speeding up BFGS Rules for Faster Second-Order Optimization »
Robert Gower · Filip Hanzely · Peter Richtarik · Sebastian Stich -
2018 Poster: Sparsified SGD with Memory »
Sebastian Stich · Jean-Baptiste Cordonnier · Martin Jaggi -
2017 Poster: Safe Adaptive Importance Sampling »
Sebastian Stich · Anant Raj · Martin Jaggi -
2017 Spotlight: Safe Adaptive Importance Sampling »
Sebastian Stich · Anant Raj · Martin Jaggi