Timezone: »
Policy Space Response Oracles (PSRO) is a reinforcement learning (RL) algorithm for two-player zero-sum games that has been empirically shown to find approximate Nash equilibria in large games. Although PSRO is guaranteed to converge to an approximate Nash equilibrium and can handle continuous actions, it may take an exponential number of iterations as the number of information states (infostates) grows. We propose Extensive-Form Double Oracle (XDO), an extensive-form double oracle algorithm for two-player zero-sum games that is guaranteed to converge to an approximate Nash equilibrium linearly in the number of infostates. Unlike PSRO, which mixes best responses at the root of the game, XDO mixes best responses at every infostate. We also introduce Neural XDO (NXDO), where the best response is learned through deep RL. In tabular experiments on Leduc poker, we find that XDO achieves an approximate Nash equilibrium in a number of iterations an order of magnitude smaller than PSRO. Experiments on a modified Leduc poker game and Oshi-Zumo show that tabular XDO achieves a lower exploitability than CFR with the same amount of computation. We also find that NXDO outperforms PSRO and NFSP on a sequential multidimensional continuous-action game. NXDO is the first deep RL method that can find an approximate Nash equilibrium in high-dimensional continuous-action sequential games.
Author Information
Stephen McAleer (UC Irvine)
JB Lanier (University of California Irvine)
Kevin A Wang (UC Irvine)
Applying to PhD programs for Fall 2022
Pierre Baldi (UC Irvine)
Roy Fox (UC Irvine)
[Roy Fox](http://roydfox.com/) is a postdoc at UC Berkeley working with [Ion Stoica](http://people.eecs.berkeley.edu/~istoica/) in the Real-Time Intelligent Secure Explainable lab ([RISELab](https://rise.cs.berkeley.edu/)), and with [Ken Goldberg](http://goldberg.berkeley.edu/) in the Laboratory for Automation Science and Engineering ([AUTOLAB](http://autolab.berkeley.edu/)). His research interests include reinforcement learning, dynamical systems, information theory, automation, and the connections between these fields. His current research focuses on automatic discovery of hierarchical control structures in deep reinforcement learning and in imitation learning of robotic tasks. Roy holds a MSc in Computer Science from the [Technion](http://www.cs.technion.ac.il/), under the supervision of [Moshe Tennenholtz](http://iew3.technion.ac.il/Home/Users/Moshet.phtml), and a PhD in Computer Science from the [Hebrew University](http://www.cs.huji.ac.il/), under the supervision of [Naftali Tishby](http://www.cs.huji.ac.il/~tishby/). He was an exchange PhD student with [Larry Abbott](http://www.cs.huji.ac.il/~tishby/) and [Liam Paninski](http://www.stat.columbia.edu/~liam/) at the [Center for Theoretical Neuroscience](http://www.neurotheory.columbia.edu/) at Columbia University, and a research intern at Microsoft Research.
More from the Same Authors
-
2021 : Temporal-Difference Value Estimation via Uncertainty-Guided Soft Updates »
Litian Liang · Yaosheng Xu · Stephen McAleer · Dailin Hu · Alexander Ihler · Pieter Abbeel · Roy Fox -
2021 : Target Entropy Annealing for Discrete Soft Actor-Critic »
Yaosheng Xu · Dailin Hu · Litian Liang · Stephen McAleer · Pieter Abbeel · Roy Fox -
2021 : Count-Based Temperature Scheduling for Maximum Entropy Reinforcement Learning »
Dailin Hu · Pieter Abbeel · Roy Fox -
2021 : Deep learning reconstruction of the neutrino energy with a shallow Askaryan detector »
Stephen McAleer · Christian Glaser · Pierre Baldi -
2021 : G-SpaNet: Generalized Permutationless Set Assignment for Particle Physics using Symmetry Preserving Attention »
Alexander Shmakov · Shih-chieh Hsu · Pierre Baldi -
2022 : Geometry-aware Autoregressive Models for Calorimeter Shower Simulations »
Junze Liu · Aishik Ghosh · Dylan Smith · Pierre Baldi · Daniel Whiteson -
2022 : Foundations of Attention Mechanisms in Deep Neural Network Architectures »
Pierre Baldi · Roman Vershynin -
2022 : Feasible Adversarial Robust Reinforcement Learning for Underspecified Environments »
JB Lanier · Stephen McAleer · Pierre Baldi · Roy Fox -
2022 : Foundations of Attention Mechanisms in Deep Neural Network Architectures »
Pierre Baldi · Roman Vershynin -
2021 Poster: Neural Auto-Curricula in Two-Player Zero-Sum Games »
Xidong Feng · Oliver Slumbers · Ziyu Wan · Bo Liu · Stephen McAleer · Ying Wen · Jun Wang · Yaodong Yang -
2020 Poster: Pipeline PSRO: A Scalable Approach for Finding Approximate Nash Equilibria in Large Games »
Stephen McAleer · JB Lanier · Roy Fox · Pierre Baldi -
2019 : Poster and Coffee Break 2 »
Karol Hausman · Kefan Dong · Ken Goldberg · Lihong Li · Lin Yang · Lingxiao Wang · Lior Shani · Liwei Wang · Loren Amdahl-Culleton · Lucas Cassano · Marc Dymetman · Marc Bellemare · Marcin Tomczak · Margarita Castro · Marius Kloft · Marius-Constantin Dinu · Markus Holzleitner · Martha White · Mengdi Wang · Michael Jordan · Mihailo Jovanovic · Ming Yu · Minshuo Chen · Moonkyung Ryu · Muhammad Zaheer · Naman Agarwal · Nan Jiang · Niao He · Nikolaus Yasui · Nikos Karampatziakis · Nino Vieillard · Ofir Nachum · Olivier Pietquin · Ozan Sener · Pan Xu · Parameswaran Kamalaruban · Paul Mineiro · Paul Rolland · Philip Amortila · Pierre-Luc Bacon · Prakash Panangaden · Qi Cai · Qiang Liu · Quanquan Gu · Raihan Seraj · Richard Sutton · Rick Valenzano · Robert Dadashi · Rodrigo Toro Icarte · Roshan Shariff · Roy Fox · Ruosong Wang · Saeed Ghadimi · Samuel Sokota · Sean Sinclair · Sepp Hochreiter · Sergey Levine · Sergio Valcarcel Macua · Sham Kakade · Shangtong Zhang · Sheila McIlraith · Shie Mannor · Shimon Whiteson · Shuai Li · Shuang Qiu · Wai Lok Li · Siddhartha Banerjee · Sitao Luan · Tamer Basar · Thinh Doan · Tianhe Yu · Tianyi Liu · Tom Zahavy · Toryn Klassen · Tuo Zhao · Vicenç Gómez · Vincent Liu · Volkan Cevher · Wesley Suttle · Xiao-Wen Chang · Xiaohan Wei · Xiaotong Liu · Xingguo Li · Xinyi Chen · Xingyou Song · Yao Liu · YiDing Jiang · Yihao Feng · Yilun Du · Yinlam Chow · Yinyu Ye · Yishay Mansour · · Yonathan Efroni · Yongxin Chen · Yuanhao Wang · Bo Dai · Chen-Yu Wei · Harsh Shrivastava · Hongyang Zhang · Qinqing Zheng · SIDDHARTHA SATPATHI · Xueqing Liu · Andreu Vall -
2019 : Coffee Break & Poster Session »
Samia Mohinta · Andrea Agostinelli · Alexandra Moringen · Jee Hang Lee · Yat Long Lo · Wolfgang Maass · Blue Sheffer · Colin Bredenberg · Benjamin Eysenbach · Liyu Xia · Efstratios Markou · Jan Lichtenberg · Pierre Richemond · Tony Zhang · JB Lanier · Baihan Lin · William Fedus · Glen Berseth · Marta Sarrico · Matthew Crosby · Stephen McAleer · Sina Ghiassian · Franz Scherr · Guillaume Bellec · Darjan Salaj · Arinbjörn Kolbeinsson · Matthew Rosenberg · Jaehoon Shin · Sang Wan Lee · Guillermo Cecchi · Irina Rish · Elias Hajek -
2019 Poster: Modeling Dynamic Functional Connectivity with Latent Factor Gaussian Processes »
Lingge Li · Dustin Pluta · Babak Shahbaba · Norbert Fortin · Hernando Ombao · Pierre Baldi -
2018 : Discussion Panel: Ryan Adams, Nicolas Heess, Leslie Kaelbling, Shie Mannor, Emo Todorov (moderator: Roy Fox) »
Ryan Adams · Nicolas Heess · Leslie Kaelbling · Shie Mannor · Emo Todorov · Roy Fox -
2018 : Spotlights 2 »
Aditya Gopalan · Sungjoon Choi · Thomas Ringstrom · Roy Fox · Jonas Degrave · Xiya Cao · Karl Pertsch · Maximilian Igl · Brian Ichter -
2018 : Opening Remarks »
Roy Fox -
2018 Workshop: Infer to Control: Probabilistic Reinforcement Learning and Structured Control »
Leslie Kaelbling · Martin Riedmiller · Marc Toussaint · Igor Mordatch · Roy Fox · Tuomas Haarnoja -
2018 : Poster Session 1 + Coffee »
Tom Van de Wiele · Rui Zhao · J. Fernando Hernandez-Garcia · Fabio Pardo · Xian Yeow Lee · Xiaolin Andy Li · Marcin Andrychowicz · Jie Tang · Suraj Nair · Juhyeon Lee · Cédric Colas · S. M. Ali Eslami · Yen-Chen Wu · Stephen McAleer · Ryan Julian · Yang Xue · Matthia Sabatelli · Pranav Shyam · Alexandros Kalousis · Giovanni Montana · Emanuele Pesce · Felix Leibfried · Zhanpeng He · Chunxiao Liu · Yanjun Li · Yoshihide Sawada · Alexander Pashevich · Tejas Kulkarni · Keiran Paster · Luca Rigazio · Quan Vuong · Hyunggon Park · Minhae Kwon · Rivindu Weerasekera · Shamane Siriwardhanaa · Rui Wang · Ozsel Kilinc · Keith Ross · Yizhou Wang · Simon Schmitt · Thomas Anthony · Evan Cater · Forest Agostinelli · Tegg Sung · Shirou Maruyama · Alexander Shmakov · Devin Schwab · Mohammad Firouzi · Glen Berseth · Denis Osipychev · Jesse Farebrother · Jianlan Luo · William Agnew · Peter Vrancx · Jonathan Heek · Catalin Ionescu · Haiyan Yin · Megumi Miyashita · Nathan Jay · Noga H. Rotman · Sam Leroux · Shaileshh Bojja Venkatakrishnan · Henri Schmidt · Jack Terwilliger · Ishan Durugkar · Jonathan Sauder · David Kas · Arash Tavakoli · Alain-Sam Cohen · Philip Bontrager · Adam Lerer · Thomas Paine · Ahmed Khalifa · Ruben Rodriguez · Avi Singh · Yiming Zhang -
2018 Poster: On Neuronal Capacity »
Pierre Baldi · Roman Vershynin -
2018 Oral: On Neuronal Capacity »
Pierre Baldi · Roman Vershynin -
2017 : Panel Discussion »
Matt Botvinick · Emma Brunskill · Marcos Campos · Jan Peters · Doina Precup · David Silver · Josh Tenenbaum · Roy Fox -
2017 : Opening Remarks »
Roy Fox -
2017 Workshop: Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning »
Andrew G Barto · Doina Precup · Shie Mannor · Tom Schaul · Roy Fox · Carlos Florensa -
2017 : Poster session »
Abbas Zaidi · Christoph Kurz · David Heckerman · YiJyun Lin · Stefan Riezler · Ilya Shpitser · Songbai Yan · Olivier Goudet · Yash Deshpande · Judea Pearl · Jovana Mitrovic · Brian Vegetabile · Tae Hwy Lee · Karen Sachs · Karthika Mohan · Reagan Rose · Julius Ramakers · Negar Hassanpour · Pierre Baldi · Razieh Nabi · Noah Hammarlund · Eli Sherman · Carolin Lawrence · Fattaneh Jabbari · Vira Semenova · Maria Dimakopoulou · Pratik Gajane · Russell Greiner · Ilias Zadik · Alexander Blocker · Hao Xu · Tal EL HAY · Tony Jebara · Benoit Rostykus -
2014 Workshop: High-energy particle physics, machine learning, and the HiggsML data challenge (HEPML) »
Glen Cowan · Balázs Kégl · Kyle Cranmer · Gábor Melis · Tim Salimans · Vladimir Vava Gligorov · Daniel Whiteson · Lester Mackey · Wojciech Kotlowski · Roberto Díaz Morales · Pierre Baldi · Cecile Germain · David Rousseau · Isabelle Guyon · Tianqi Chen -
2014 Poster: Searching for Higgs Boson Decay Modes with Deep Learning »
Peter Sadowski · Daniel Whiteson · Pierre Baldi -
2014 Spotlight: Searching for Higgs Boson Decay Modes with Deep Learning »
Peter Sadowski · Daniel Whiteson · Pierre Baldi -
2013 Poster: Understanding Dropout »
Pierre Baldi · Peter Sadowski -
2013 Oral: Understanding Dropout »
Pierre Baldi · Peter Sadowski -
2012 Poster: Deep Spatio-Temporal Architectures and Learning for Protein Structure Prediction »
Pietro Di Lena · Pierre Baldi · Ken Nagata -
2012 Spotlight: Deep Spatio-Temporal Architectures and Learning for Protein Structure Prediction »
Pietro Di Lena · Pierre Baldi · Ken Nagata -
2011 Poster: A Machine Learning Approach to Predict Chemical Reactions »
Matthew A Kayala · Pierre Baldi -
2010 Workshop: Charting Chemical Space: Challenges and Opportunities for AI and Machine Learning »
Pierre Baldi · Klaus-Robert Müller · Gisbert Schneider -
2007 Poster: Mining Internet-Scale Software Repositories »
Erik Linstead · Paul Rigor, Ph.D. · sushil bajracharya · cristina lopes · Pierre Baldi -
2006 Poster: A Scalable Machine Learning Approach to Go »
Lin Wu · Pierre Baldi -
2006 Talk: A Scalable Machine Learning Approach to Go »
Lin Wu · Pierre Baldi