Timezone: »
Recent work in theoretical neuroscience has shown that information-theoretic "efficient" neural codes, which allocate neural resources to maximize the mutual information between stimuli and neural responses, give rise to a lawful relationship between perceptual bias and discriminability that is observed across a wide variety of psychophysical tasks in human observers (Wei & Stocker 2017). Here we generalize these results to show that the same law arises under a much larger family of optimal neural codes, introducing a unifying framework that we call power-law efficient coding. Specifically, we show that the same lawful relationship between bias and discriminability arises whenever Fisher information is allocated proportional to any power of the prior distribution. This family includes neural codes that are optimal for minimizing Lp error for any p, indicating that the lawful relationship observed in human psychophysical data does not require information-theoretically optimal neural codes. Furthermore, we derive the exact constant of proportionality governing the relationship between bias and discriminability for different power laws (which includes information-theoretically optimal codes, where the power is 2, and so-called discrimax codes, where power is 1/2), and different choices of optimal decoder. As a bonus, our framework provides new insights into "anti-Bayesian" perceptual biases, in which percepts are biased away from the center of mass of the prior. We derive an explicit formula that clarifies precisely which combinations of neural encoder and decoder can give rise to such biases.
Author Information
Michael J Morais (Princeton University)
Jonathan Pillow (Princeton University)
More from the Same Authors
-
2021 : Neural Latents Benchmark ‘21: Evaluating latent variable models of neural population activity »
Felix Pei · Joel Ye · David Zoltowski · Anqi Wu · Raeed Chowdhury · Hansem Sohn · Joseph O'Doherty · Krishna V Shenoy · Matthew Kaufman · Mark Churchland · Mehrdad Jazayeri · Lee Miller · Jonathan Pillow · Il Memming Park · Eva Dyer · Chethan Pandarinath -
2022 : Non-exchangeability in Infinite Switching Linear Dynamical Systems »
Victor Geadah · Jonathan Pillow -
2022 Poster: Dynamic Inverse Reinforcement Learning for Characterizing Animal Behavior »
Zoe Ashwood · Aditi Jha · Jonathan Pillow -
2022 Poster: Extracting computational mechanisms from neural data using low-rank RNNs »
Adrian Valente · Jonathan Pillow · Srdjan Ostojic -
2020 Poster: High-contrast “gaudy” images improve the training of deep neural network models of visual cortex »
Benjamin Cowley · Jonathan Pillow -
2020 Poster: Identifying signal and noise structure in neural population activity with Gaussian process factor models »
Stephen Keeley · Mikio Aoi · Yiyi Yu · Spencer Smith · Jonathan Pillow -
2020 Poster: Inferring learning rules from animal decision-making »
Zoe Ashwood · Nicholas Roy · Ji Hyun Bak · Jonathan Pillow -
2018 Poster: Scaling the Poisson GLM to massive neural datasets through polynomial approximations »
David Zoltowski · Jonathan Pillow -
2018 Poster: Efficient inference for time-varying behavior during learning »
Nicholas Roy · Ji Hyun Bak · Athena Akrami · Carlos Brody · Jonathan Pillow -
2018 Poster: Model-based targeted dimensionality reduction for neuronal population data »
Mikio Aoi · Jonathan Pillow -
2018 Poster: Learning a latent manifold of odor representations from neural responses in piriform cortex »
Anqi Wu · Stan Pashkovski · Sandeep Datta · Jonathan Pillow -
2017 Poster: Gaussian process based nonlinear latent structure discovery in multivariate spike train data »
Anqi Wu · Nicholas Roy · Stephen Keeley · Jonathan Pillow -
2016 Poster: Bayesian latent structure discovery from multi-neuron recordings »
Scott Linderman · Ryan Adams · Jonathan Pillow -
2016 Poster: Adaptive optimal training of animal behavior »
Ji Hyun Bak · Jung Choi · Ilana Witten · Athena Akrami · Jonathan Pillow -
2016 Poster: A Bayesian method for reducing bias in neural representational similarity analysis »
Mingbo Cai · Nicolas W Schuck · Jonathan Pillow · Yael Niv -
2015 Poster: Convolutional spike-triggered covariance analysis for neural subunit models »
Anqi Wu · Il Memming Park · Jonathan Pillow