Timezone: »

Fairness Behind a Veil of Ignorance: A Welfare Analysis for Automated Decision Making
Hoda Heidari · Claudio Ferrari · Krishna Gummadi · Andreas Krause

Wed Dec 05 07:45 AM -- 09:45 AM (PST) @ Room 517 AB #137

We draw attention to an important, yet largely overlooked aspect of evaluating fairness for automated decision making systems---namely risk and welfare considerations. Our proposed family of measures corresponds to the long-established formulations of cardinal social welfare in economics, and is justified by the Rawlsian conception of fairness behind a veil of ignorance. The convex formulation of our welfare-based measures of fairness allows us to integrate them as a constraint into any convex loss minimization pipeline. Our empirical analysis reveals interesting trade-offs between our proposal and (a) prediction accuracy, (b) group discrimination, and (c) Dwork et al's notion of individual fairness. Furthermore and perhaps most importantly, our work provides both heuristic justification and empirical evidence suggesting that a lower-bound on our measures often leads to bounded inequality in algorithmic outcomes; hence presenting the first computationally feasible mechanism for bounding individual-level inequality.

Author Information

Hoda Heidari (ETH Zürich)
Claudio Ferrari (ETH Zürich)
Krishna Gummadi (Max Planck Institute for Software Systems)
Andreas Krause (ETH Zurich)

More from the Same Authors